| Points | 
 | 
 | 
 | 
| Scored | Name |  | Results | 
| 53 | George Duncan | Humboldt (vs. Cleveland, 1/28/1910) | 84-6 W | 
| 51 | Hank Riehm | Monroe (vs. Humboldt, 2/4/1964) | 67-63 W | 
| 47 | Ken Reed | Harding (vs. Humboldt, 2/4/2013) | 74-69 W | 
| 44 | Dion Bradley | Highland Park (vs. Washington, 1/22/2013) | 101-40 W | 
| 44 | Shawn Huberty | Washington (vs. Highland Park, 1/25/2024) | 83-66 L | 
| 43 | Curtis Bell | Washington (vs. Central, 1/27/2017) | 81-69 L | 
| 42 | Pete Monson | Washington (vs. Humboldt, 1/20/1976) | 69-52 W | 
| 42 | Demeris Allen | Como Park (vs. Highland Park, 2/7/1997) | 81-70 L | 
| 42 | Tierre Davis | Harding (vs. Washington, 2/19/2019) | 85-64 W | 
| 41 | Manuel Mitchell | Harding (vs. Humboldt, 2/8/2000) | 92-88 L | 
| 41 | Steve Sir | Cretin-Derham (vs. Como Park, 2/27/2001) | 86-76 W | 
| 41 | Mike Keating | Cretin-Derham (vs. Humboldt, 1/15/2002) | 85-68 W | 
| 41 | Demond Dawson | Humboldt (vs. Washington, 1/10/2014) | 84-73 L | 
| 41 | Carter Owens | Highland Park (vs. Washington, 2/4/2020) | 86-75 W | 
| 40 | Reid Mahon | Como Park (vs. Harding, 2/2/1999) | 77-65 L | 
| 40 | Demetrice Mitchell | Como Park (vs. Johnson, 2/5/2014) | 108-96 L | 
| 40 | Allan Lankfard, Jr. | Central (vs. Harding, 2/19/2025) | 80-48 W | 
| 39 | Chuck Shelton | Mechanic Arts (vs. Johnson, 2/12/1974) | 77-47 W | 
| 39 | Mike Heller | St. Thomas (vs. Johnson, 2/15/1979) | 82-25 W | 
| 39 | Dylan Hale | Central (vs. Arlington, 2/26/2008) | 99-76 W | 
| 39 | Marion Moore | Humboldt (vs. Como Park, 2/7/2014) | 111-104 L | 
| 39 | Carter Owens | Highland Park (vs. Washington, 1/9/2020) | 80-75 W | 
| 39 | Ty'Quan Allen | Washington (vs. Humboldt, 2/17/2023) | 82-78 L | 
| 38 | Stan Hill | Central (vs. Washington, 2/13/1973) | 68-63 W | 
| 38 | Juriad Hughes | Central (vs. Cretin-Derham, 12/20/1988) | 83-65 W | 
| 38 | Andy Carter | Central (vs. Arlington, 2/20/1998) | 85-77 W | 
| 38 | Bryale Winters | Humboldt (vs. Arlington, 1/12/2010) | 68-51 W | 
| 38 | Curtis Bell | Washington (vs. Johnson, 1/24/2017) | 87-85 L |