| Yards | Name | Team (Opponent, Date) | 
| 48 | Pete Schletz | Cretin-Derham (vs. Central, 10/2/1997) | 
| 45 | Pete Schletz | Cretin-Derham (vs. Arlington, 9/26/1997) | 
| 43 | Bill Peterson | Central (vs. Mechanic Arts, 10/19/1956) | 
| 43 | George Griesgraber | Highland Park (vs. Johnson, 9/9/1983) | 
| 42 | Randy Quale | Murray (vs. Johnson, 9/20/1974) | 
| 42 | Matt Croucher | Harding (vs. Como Park, 9/12/1987) | 
| 40 | James Dunn | Mechanic Arts (vs. Central, 11/2/1923) | 
| 40 | Rick Printon | Johnson (vs. Highland Park, 10/14/1976) | 
| 40 | Ben Ryan | Central (vs. Highland Park, 9/24/2011) | 
| 39 | Jeff Rosga | Cretin-Derham (vs. Johnson, 10/3/1987) | 
| 38 | Randy Quale | Murray (vs. Highland Park, 9/24/1976) | 
| 38 | Jim Misgen | Hill-Murray (vs. Harding, 9/13/1985) | 
| 38 | Ben Ryan | Central (vs. Highland Park, 9/24/2011) | 
| 38 | Richie Gulner | Como Park (vs. Central, 10/16/2013) | 
| 37 | Howie Coan | Harding (vs. St. Thomas, 10/18/1978) | 
| 37 | Joey Silversmith | Highland Park (vs. Harding, 9/28/2012) | 
| 35 | Sammy Kaufman | Johnson (vs. Central, 10/12/1923) | 
| 35 | Mike Printon | Johnson (vs. Central, 10/5/1972) | 
| 35 | Dave Schleichert | Humboldt (vs. Mechanic Arts, 9/28/1973) | 
| 35 | Tyler Sauser | Harding (vs. Humboldt, 8/29/2003) |