| 
 
|  |  |  | Games | Points |   
| Year | Name | Team | Played | Scored |   
| 1900 | William Brennan | Central | 1 | 7 |   
| 1901 | Harvey Barnett | Central | 2 | 5 |   
|  | Robert Jacobson | Mechanic Arts | 2 | 5 |   
|  | Henry O'Brien | Central | 2 | 5 |   
| 1902 | Ralph Rader | Central | 1 | 27 |   
| 1903 | Wykoff Clark | Central | 1 | 5 |   
| 1904 | Will Fitzsimmons | Central | 1 | 20 |   
| 1907 | Art Erdall | Mechanic Arts | 1 | 10 |   
| 1908 | Carl Haedge | Mechanic Arts | 1 | 7 |   
| 1909 | Paul Robert | Central | 1 | 11 |   
| 1910 | Anthony Tomasek | Central | 2 | 15 |   
| 1911 | Bill Stickney | Central | 3 | 41 |   
| 1912 | Bill Stickney | Central | 2 | 34 |   
| 1913 | Steve Hopkins | Mechanic Arts | 3 | 18 |   
| 1914 | Steve Hopkins | Mechanic Arts | 3 | 42 |   
| 1915 | Percy Bagley | Central | 3 | 24 |   
| 1916 | Reginald Goette | Mechanic Arts | 3 | 30 |   
| 1917 | Harry Fryer | Humboldt | 2 | 24 |   
| 1918 | Cornelius Barnes | Central | 3 | 36 |   
|  | Steve French | Central | 3 | 36 |   
| 1919 | Perry Copeland | Mechanic Arts | 3 | 57 |   
| 1920 | Cy Ettinger | Humboldt | 3 | 33 |   
| 1921 | Jack Eaton | Mechanic Arts | 3 | 48 |   
| 1922 | Willard Falk | Central | 3 | 36 |   
| 1923 | Jack Meisen | Central | 3 | 24 |   
| 1924 | Rube Wagner | Mechanic Arts | 3 | 30 |   
| 1925 | Ed Ziegler | Mechanic Arts | 3 | 30 |   
| 1926 | Ron Golden | Central | 3 | 19 |   
| 1927 | Russell Deach | Mechanic Arts | 3 | 30 |   
|  | Lawrence Johnson | Central | 3 | 30 |   
| 1928 | Ron Golden | Central | 3 | 25 |   
| 1929 | Arnold Mentes | Mechanic Arts | 4 | 41 |   
| 1930 | Bill Bevan | Central | 4 | 29 |   
| 1931 | Clarence Courtney | Humboldt | 4 | 36 |   
| 1932 | Albin Anderson | Central | 5 | 40 |   
| 1933 | Ken Hunt | Washington | 5 | 31 |   
| 1934 | Jack Campbell | Central | 5 | 75 |   
| 1935 | George Katz | Washington | 5 | 30 |   
| 1936 | Art Kaess | Washington | 5 | 31 |   
| 1937 | Harold Peterfeso | Johnson | 5 | 34 |   
| 1938 | Stan Smith | Washington | 5 | 55 |   
| 1939 | Bob Graiziger | Washington | 5 | 43 |   
| 1940 | Tom Syfko | Harding | 5 | 24 |   
| 1941 | Jack Clemens | Central | 7 | 73 |   
| 1942 | Glen Clark | Johnson | 7 | 50 |   
| 1943 | Vernon Stromberg | Wilson | 7 | 48 |   
| 1944 | Jerry Kelly | Mechanic Arts | 7 | 60 |   
| 1945 | Bob Vogel | Harding | 7 | 84 |   
| 1946 | Joe Phillips | Wilson | 7 | 55 |   
| 1947 | Scott Prescott | Wilson | 7 | 54 |   
| 1948 | Nick Combs | Marshall | 7 | 59 |   
| 1949 | Bill Follmer | Washington | 7 | 48 |   
| 1950 | Roger Lingofelt | Central | 7 | 42 |   
| 1951 | Franz Koeneke | Murray | 8 | 50 |   
| 1952 | Dick Lange | Johnson | 8 | 98 |   
| 1953 | Bob Blakley | Central | 7 | 69 |   
| 1954 | Bob Blakley | Central | 7 | 85 |   
| 1955 | Chris Nicosia | Harding | 7 | 66 |   
| 1956 | Kurt King | Monroe | 7 | 58 |   
| 1957 | Denny Davis | Humboldt | 7 | 64 |   
| 1958 | Dugal McLellan | Harding | 7 | 60 |   
| 1959 | Dugal McLellan | Harding | 7 | 60 |   
| 1960 | Tom Barnes | Central | 7 | 60 |   
| 1961 | Bruce VanDeWalker | Washington | 7 | 52 |   
| 1962 | Charley Woodbury | Wilson | 8 | 65 |   
| 1963 | Bill Price | Mechanic Arts | 8 | 74 |   
| 1964 | Tom Hardy | Central | 8 | 55 |   
| 1965 | Ray Hessler | Humboldt | 8 | 72 |   
| 1966 | Al Montgomery | Washington | 8 | 69 |   
| 1967 | Lenny Sanchez | Humboldt | 8 | 61 |   
| 1968 | Clyde Thomas | Central | 8 | 80 |   
| 1969 | Ollie Bakken | Harding | 8 | 102 |   
| 1970 | Tom Sundberg | Harding | 8 | 62 |   
| 1971 | Tom Sundberg | Harding | 8 | 66 |   
| 1972 | Dave Dunnigan | Central | 8 | 72 |   
| 1973 | Ron Shimon | Harding | 8 | 54 |   
| 1974 | Reed Hess | Harding | 8 | 96 |   
| 1975 | Brad Pecelj | Harding | 8 | 110 |   
| 1976 | Dave Lundquist | Harding | 7 | 72 |   
| 1977 | Lou Raiola | Johnson | 9 | 92 |   
| 1978 | Sean Maher | St. Thomas | 9 | 82 |   
| 1979 | Ben Strub | Johnson | 8 | 68 |   
| 1980 | Mark Lingofelt | St. Thomas | 8 | 48 |   
|  | Greg Murphy | Cretin | 8 | 48 |   
| 1981 | Ray Tilmon | Harding | 8 | 74 |   
| 1982 | Tony Adkins | Johnson | 8 | 72 |   
| 1983 | Rob Oberfrank | Como Park | 8 | 70 |   
| 1984 | Steve Schneider | Cretin | 8 | 55 |   
| 1985 | Colin Glidden | Cretin | 8 | 90 |   
| 1986 | Jerry Czech | Cretin | 8 | 60 |   
| 1987 | Dan Walsh | Cretin-Derham | 6 | 62 |   
| 1988 | Dan Walsh | Cretin-Derham | 5 | 66 |   
| 1989 | Robert Dunaski | Como Park | 6 | 42 |   
|  | Brad Larson | Johnson | 6 | 42 |   
|  | Todd Moss | Johnson | 6 | 42 |   
| 1990 | Terrence Jackson | Como Park | 6 | 76 |   
| 1991 | Carl McCullough | Cretin-Derham | 5 | 92 |   
| 1992 | Tommy Reynolds | Johnson | 6 | 80 |   
| 1993 | Tommy Reynolds | Johnson | 6 | 90 |   
| 1994 | Verdis Webb | Cretin-Derham | 6 | 72 |   
| 1995 | Mike Lyons | Johnson | 6 | 70 |   
| 1996 | Jerry Burch | Cretin-Derham | 6 | 60 |   
| 1997 | Thomas Tapeh | Johnson | 7 | 138 |   
| 1998 | Thomas Tapeh | Johnson | 7 | 158 |   
| 1999 | Kim Sarin | Cretin-Derham | 7 | 84 |   
| 2000 | Rashon Powers-Neal | Cretin-Derham | 7 | 138 |   
| 2001 | Kim Sarin | Cretin-Derham | 7 | 128 |   
| 2002 | Marcus Ross | Johnson | 6 | 72 |   
| 2003 | Joe Balsimo | Johnson | 6 | 66 |   
| 2004 | Mychel Stowers | Central | 6 | 62 |   
| 2005 | Chris Atkins | Johnson | 6 | 108 |   
| 2006 | Chris Atkins | Johnson | 6 | 96 |   
| 2007 | Saladin Broadway | Como Park | 6 | 66 |   
| 2008 | Terrance Williams | Como Park | 6 | 78 |   
| 2009 | Jeremy Hallowanger | Harding | 5 | 56 |   
| 2010 | Andrew Lewis | Central | 5 | 62 |   
| 2011 | Davion Johnson | Central | 5 | 62 |   
| 2012 | Gabe Walker | Central | 5 | 64 |   
| 2013 | Isaiah Brower | Highland Park | 5 | 96 |   
| 2014 | Garrett Gardner | Central | 4 | 84 |    |