| Goals | 
 | 
 | 
| Scored | Name |  | 
| 10 | Milton Bach | Mechanic Arts (vs. Johnson, 1/28/1916) | 
| 10 | Willard Falk | Central (vs. Johnson, 1/27/1922) | 
| 9 | Frank Fitzell | Mechanic Arts (vs. Johnson, 1/13/1922) | 
| 7 | Greg Tonn | Humboldt (vs. Central, 12/18/1967) | 
| 7 | John Paitich | Washington (vs. Central, 12/27/1978) | 
| 6 | George DeVinney | Mechanic Arts (vs. Johnson, 1/3/1913) | 
| 6 | Dan Hickey | Mechanic Arts (vs. Johnson, 1/3/1913) | 
| 6 | Walter Yungbauer | Central (vs. Johnson, 1/7/1921) | 
| 6 | Walter Yungbauer | Central (vs. Johnson, 1/27/1921) | 
| 6 | Milford Munson | Mechanic Arts (vs. Washington, 2/13/1930) | 
| 6 | George Path | Washington (vs. Central, 1/12/1940) | 
| 6 | Julius Struntz | Washington (vs. Monroe, 1/31/1945) | 
| 6 | Gene Lowe | Harding (vs. Marshall, 1/15/1947) | 
| 6 | Duane Thompson | Harding (vs. Washington, 12/26/1951) | 
| 6 | Stan Blom | Johnson (vs. Humboldt, 2/10/1971) | 
| 6 | Tom Sundberg | Harding (vs. Humboldt, 12/11/1971) | 
| 6 | Mike Haedrich | Monroe (vs. Humboldt, 2/3/1973) | 
| 6 | John Alexander | Highland Park (vs. Monroe, 1/14/1976) | 
| 6 | Dewey Wahlin | Johnson (vs. Highland Park, 12/14/1983) | 
| 6 | Dewey Wahlin | Johnson (vs. Central, 1/25/1984) | 
| 6 | Jim Hau | Johnson (vs. Highland Park, 1/28/1984) | 
| 6 | Greg Pogreba | Johnson (vs. Humboldt, 1/15/1992) | 
| 5 | Wilfred Garrett | Central (vs. Humboldt, 1/29/1916) | 
| 5 | Walter Yungbauer | Central (vs. Humboldt, 1/14/1921) | 
| 5 | Willard Falk | Central (vs. Humboldt, 2/2/1922) | 
| 5 | Harold Goodwillie | Mechanic Arts (vs. Johnson, 1/20/1928) | 
| 5 | Arnold Bauer | Johnson (vs. Mechanic Arts, 1/8/1942) | 
| 5 | Bill Klatt | Johnson (vs. Monroe, 2/12/1944) | 
| 5 | Frank Macioch | Washington (vs. Marshall, 1/8/1947) | 
| 5 | Gene Lowe | Harding (vs. Central, 1/10/1948) | 
| 5 | Carl Weber | Humboldt (vs. Monroe, 1/17/1953) | 
| 5 | Ron VonDeLinde | Harding (vs. Highland Park, 1/16/1965) | 
| 5 | Scott Frantzen | Johnson (vs. Mechanic Arts, 1/3/1968) | 
| 5 | Greg Tonn | Humboldt (vs. Mechanic Arts, 1/10/1968) | 
| 5 | Steve DelMonico | Washington (vs. Mechanic Arts, 12/23/1968) | 
| 5 | Tom Broneak | Highland Park (vs. Central, 1/5/1972) | 
| 5 | Mike Haedrich | Monroe (vs. Humboldt, 2/20/1972) | 
| 5 | Gary Moravec | Monroe (vs. Washington, 1/6/1973) | 
| 5 | Joe Ricci | Johnson (vs. Monroe, 1/25/1975) | 
| 5 | Brian Sherrick | Harding (vs. Highland Park, 12/13/1980) | 
| 5 | Jeff Sura | Humboldt (vs. Central, 12/15/1980) | 
| 5 | Dave Hawkinson | Johnson (vs. Highland Park, 1/24/1981) | 
| 5 | Jim Nielsen | Humboldt (vs. Highland Park, 2/14/1981) | 
| 5 | Sean Toomey | Cretin (vs. Central, 12/9/1981) | 
| 5 | John Jacks | Highland Park (vs. Central, 2/9/1983) | 
| 5 | Dewey Wahlin | Johnson (vs. Como Park, 1/11/1984) | 
| 5 | Joe Schwartz | Harding (vs. Highland Park, 1/25/1984) | 
| 5 | Dewey Wahlin | Johnson (vs. Humboldt, 2/8/1984) | 
| 5 | Tom Graske | Hill-Murray (vs. Central, 12/5/1984) | 
| 5 | Herb Harvey | Johnson (vs. Central, 12/12/1984) | 
| 5 | Mitch Converse | Johnson (vs. Humboldt, 1/5/1985) | 
| 5 | Mark Johnson | Hill-Murray (vs. Humboldt, 1/30/1985) | 
| 5 | Erik Jorgensen | Como Park (vs. Central, 12/14/1985) | 
| 5 | Brian McDonough | Humboldt (vs. Central, 12/18/1985) | 
| 5 | Tray Tuomie | Hill-Murray (vs. Central, 1/29/1986) | 
| 5 | Alec Sands | Hawks (vs. Como Park, 2/7/2004) |