| Saves | Name | Team (Opponent, Date) | 
| 69 | Kurt Haas | Wilson (vs. Humboldt, 1/2/1963, lost 4-1) | 
| 66 | Nick Novak | Murray (vs. Johnson, 12/3/1969, lost 4-0) | 
| 64 | Jon Dorn | Central (vs. Hill-Murray, 12/7/1983, lost 16-1) | 
| 60 | Steve Houge | Mechanic Arts (vs. Johnson, 1/3/1968, lost 17-1) | 
| 58 | Ron Koller | Mechanic Arts (vs. Murray, 1/23/1963, lost 8-0) | 
| 57 | Jerry Henry | Central (vs. Hill-Murray, 12/28/1977, lost 9-0) | 
| 56 | Duane Nelson | Central (vs. Johnson, 11/26/1969, lost 20-0) | 
| 56 | Luke Garafalo | Central/H.P./Hum./Arl. (vs. Como Park, 2/14/2000, lost 5-2) | 
| 56 | Luke Garafalo | Central/H.P./Hum./Arl. (vs. Cretin-DH, 1/13/2001, lost 13-1) | 
| 55 | Steve Houge | Mechanic Arts (vs. Washington, 2/1/1969, lost 7-2) | 
| 55 | Kevin Carufel | Mechanic Arts (vs. Johnson, 12/19/1970, lost 9-1) | 
| 55 | Brian Carufel | Mechanic Arts (vs. Highland Park, 1/15/1975, lost 9-3) | 
| 55 | Jon Dorn | Central (vs. Harding, 2/16/1983, lost 4-3 in overtime) | 
| 55 | Tyler Bonine | Harding (vs. Johnson, 2/5/2003, lost 7-0) |