Year	Results	Year	Results
1983	Henry 6, Hill-Murray 5	2002	Harding 12, Southwest 0
1984	Derham Hall 8, Edison 0	2003	Cretin-Derham 4, South 1
1985	Harding 9, Roosevelt 0	2005	Johnson 10, Roosevelt 0 (5 inn.)
1986	Hill-Murray 13, Washburn 3	2006	Johnson 5, Washburn 0
1987	Hill-Murray 2, Roosevelt 0	2007	Como Park 10, Washburn 0 (6 inn.)
1988	Cretin-Derham 10, Washburn 1	2008	Como Park 9, Southwest 5
1989	Cretin-Derham 10, Roosevelt 0 (6 inn.)	2009	Johnson 6, Southwest 3
1990	Cretin-Derham 9, Washburn 1	2010	Johnson 8, Washburn 2
1991	Johnson 8, Washburn 1	2011	Southwest 11, Como Park 6
1992	Cretin-Derham 6, Henry 0	2012	Johnson 13, Washburn 4
1993	Cretin-Derham 7, Henry 0	2013	Washburn 7, Como Park 0
1994	Johnson 6, South 0	2016	Highland Park 5, Southwest 4
1995	Cretin-Derham 6, Washburn 2	2017	South 6, Highland Park 2
1996	Johnson 3, Southwest 0	2019	Central 8, South 6
1997	Harding 2, South 0	2022	Central 5, Southwest 4
1999	Johnson 5, Washburn 0	2023	Highland Park 16, Southwest 6 (5 inn.)
2000	Johnson 8, Washburn 1	2024	Highland Park 6, Roosevelt 0
2001	Cretin-Derham 11, Washburn 2	2025

In 1998, 2004 and 2018, the game was cancelled due to weather.
In 2014 and 2015, the game conflicted with post-season playoffs and was cancelled.
In 2016 and 2017, the winner of the conference playoffs represented St. Paul.
In 2020, the season was cancelled because of the COVID-19 virus.
In 2021, the game was not scheduled.